Woman Says Her Hinge Date Told Her He Liked Her Because Other Men Wouldn’t — Then She Blocked Him

Photo credit: Mehaniq/Shutterstock.com

A 23-year-old woman says she blocked a Hinge date after he gave her one of the strangest explanations possible for why he was interested in her: he thought most other people would not be attracted to her, which meant he would have less competition.

She explained in a Reddit post that the man was 27 and that before the comment, he had seemed great. He was nice, funny, cool, and had called her pretty more than once. That is part of what made the moment so confusing. He had built up enough goodwill that when he suddenly said something insulting, she wondered if she was misunderstanding him.

But the comment itself was hard to soften.

According to the woman, he told her he was interested in her because most people would not be attracted to her, so he would have less competition dating her.

That is not exactly a compliment you print on a Valentine’s card.

The woman was immediately confused and offended. But instead of simply trusting that reaction, she started second-guessing herself. Maybe he did not mean it the way it sounded. Maybe he was trying to say she was uniquely attractive to him. Maybe he was awkward and insecure. Maybe the point was supposed to be flattering, and it came out badly.

Still, what he actually said landed like an insult wrapped in a dating pitch.

It also carried a controlling edge. The idea was not only that he found her attractive. It was that he liked the fact that fewer people would want her, because then he would not have to compete. In other words, part of her appeal was that he believed she had fewer options.

That is a nasty thing to say to someone you are dating, especially early on.

A person can have a specific type. A person can say, “You’re exactly my type,” or “I’m really attracted to you.” But when someone says they like you because other people probably won’t, it shifts the whole energy. It turns attraction into a power imbalance.

The woman seemed to feel that shift, even if she could not immediately explain it.

That is why blocking him made sense. She did not need to sit through more explanations about why his insult was actually a compliment. She did not need to give him another chance to rephrase it. She had enough information from the way he framed his interest.

The fact that he had called her pretty before did not erase what came after. If anything, it made it more disorienting. He could compliment her one minute, then make her feel like he was doing her a favor by dating her the next.

That kind of hot-and-cold messaging can mess with someone’s head fast. One second, you feel chosen. The next, you feel like you are being told you should be grateful because nobody else would choose you.

The post was locked, so there was no later update from the woman saying whether he apologized or tried to contact her again. But the main conflict did not need much more. He made an early dating comment that sounded insulting, insecure, and possibly manipulative. She trusted her discomfort enough to block him, then wondered if she had been too harsh.

In this case, the block button did exactly what it was made for.

Commenters overwhelmingly told her she was not overreacting. Many called the comment negging — a tactic where someone gives an insult disguised as honesty or praise to lower another person’s confidence.

A lot of people said the most concerning part was not simply that he implied she was unattractive to others. It was that he seemed pleased by the idea of having less competition. Commenters said that sounded like someone who wanted a partner with low self-esteem and fewer perceived options.

Several people pointed out that early dating is when people usually try to make their best impression. If his best impression included telling her other people would not want her, they said she did not need to stick around for the next version.

Others said he may have been insecure and clumsy with his words, but even then, that did not make the comment okay. A person’s insecurity does not give them permission to chip away at someone else’s confidence.

The strongest advice was simple: she was right to block him. A man who starts by making someone feel lucky to have his attention is not someone worth trying to decode.